Elongated Toilets vs. Round Toilets
Choosing the right toilet shape can significantly impact your bathroom’s comfort and functionality. In our comprehensive comparison guide, Elongated Toilets vs. Round Toilets, we delve into each toilet type’s key differences, benefits, and considerations.
Whether you’re renovating your bathroom or replacing an old toilet, understanding the pros and cons of elongated and round toilets will help you make an informed decision that suits your needs and preferences. From space-saving advantages to enhanced comfort, this guide covers everything you need to know to select the perfect toilet for your home.
Overview Of Elongated Toilets vs. Round Toilets
In the world of toilets, shape matters. Choosing an elongated or round toilet can impact comfort, space, and functionality.
Elongated Toilet Features
An elongated toilet has an oval-shaped bowl, often making it about 18.5 inches in length. This design offers more seating space, enhancing comfort, particularly for larger or taller individuals.
These toilets typically provide a more powerful flush, which may reduce the need for a second flush. However, their larger size means you’ll need more bathroom space to accommodate them. If your bathroom has enough room, the elongated bowl can offer many households a more comfortable and efficient option.
Round Toilet Characteristics
Round toilets have a circular bowl and measure around 16.5 inches in length, making them more compact. This shape benefits smaller bathrooms or tight spaces where every inch counts.
Though they occupy less space, round toilets might be less comfortable for some users due to the reduced seating area. Nonetheless, they are often easier to fit in various bathroom layouts. Additionally, they tend to be more affordable and can use the same amount of water as elongated models, making them an efficient choice.
Design Considerations
When choosing between Elongated Toilets vs. Round Toilets, there are key factors related to space efficiency, aesthetic preferences, and ease of cleaning that you should consider. Each type offers distinct benefits, making it important to prioritize your needs and the specific layout of your bathroom.
Space Efficiency
Elongated toilets typically measure 18.5 inches from the seat bolt holes to the front of the rim, while round toilets are usually about 16.5 inches long. This extra length means elongated toilets require more space.
If you have a small bathroom or a half bath, a round toilet might be better due to its compact size. This can leave you with more room for other fixtures and movement. Space efficiency is crucial in bathroom design, especially in homes where every square inch counts.
Aesthetic and Style
The toilet bowl’s shape can affect your bathroom’s overall look. Elongated toilets have a more modern appearance, as their sleek, oval shape is often considered stylish and contemporary.
In contrast, round toilets have a more traditional and classic look. Your choice may depend on the decor and style you want to achieve. For example, an elongated toilet might complement a modern-style bathroom, while a round toilet could fit better in a vintage or rustic design.
Ease of Cleaning
Cleaning is an important consideration when selecting a toilet. Elongated toilets can be easier to clean because their larger bowl provides better access. The extended rim allows you to reach all areas more effectively, making it simpler to maintain cleanliness.
With their compact size, round toilets might have tighter spots that can be harder to clean thoroughly. However, they are still manageable with regular maintenance. You should consider how much time you want to spend cleaning and whether ease of access to all areas of the bowl is important.
Installation and Measurements
When choosing between Elongated Toilets vs. Round Toilets, it’s crucial to consider both the installation process and the specific measurements of each type. The dimensions and requirements for each can influence how well the toilet will fit in your bathroom and how challenging it will be to install.
Toilet Measurements
Elongated toilets are generally about 18.5 inches from the mounting holes to the front of the bowl, which is two inches longer than round toilets, which average around 16.5 inches.
Standard heights for both types usually range from 14 to 16 inches, while chair height models can be between 16 and 19 inches.
Rough-in measurements are important for installation. Most toilets have a 12-inch rough-in (distance from the wall to the center of the toilet’s drainpipe), but some models might have 10 or 14 inches.
| Type | Length | Height | Rough-In |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elongated | approx. 18.5″ | 14″ to 19″ | usually 12″ |
| Round | approx. 16.5″ | 14″ to 19″ | usually 12″ |
Tank dimensions should also be considered, as a larger tank can take up additional space. Be sure to measure your bathroom accurately to ensure a comfortable fit.
Installation Requirements
The installation process for both Elongated Toilets vs. Round Toilets typically involves similar steps. You’ll need basic tools, a new wax ring, and possibly some plumbing skills.
First, remove the old toilet and clean the area. Make sure the rough-in measurement matches your new toilet. Place the wax ring on the drain outlet of the bowl before setting the toilet on the flange.
Align the mounting holes and secure the toilet with bolts. Attach the tank to the bowl (if it’s a two-piece model), and connect the water supply line.
Fill the tank with water and check for leaks. Ensure that all bolts and connections are tightened properly.
If you’re uncomfortable with these steps, hiring a professional to avoid potential issues during installation is advisable.
Functionality and Comfort
Elongated and round toilets each have unique features that affect their comfort and ease of use. These include differences in comfort, flushing technology, and accessibility.
Comfort Level
Elongated toilets generally provide more comfort for users due to their larger bowl size, typically measuring about 18.5 inches in length. This design offers more sitting space, making them ideal for taller or larger individuals. In contrast, round toilets have a shorter bowl, usually around 16.5 inches, which may feel cramped for some but can fit well in smaller bathrooms.
The elongation helps distribute weight more evenly, making these toilets more comfortable for longer sitting periods. This can be particularly beneficial for elderly users or those with chronic pain. While less spacious, round toilets can still be comfortable for those with smaller frames or limited bathroom space.
Flushing Technology
Elongated toilets often feature more advanced flush technology, which includes options like dual flush systems that offer a stronger flush. This can help reduce water consumption by allowing you to choose between a light or heavy flush. The larger trapway in elongated toilets helps prevent clogging and ensures a more powerful flush.
Round toilets may not always have these advanced features, but they still perform reliably. They are typically easier to maintain and may require less water per flush, which can be beneficial for water conservation. Both toilet types offer effective flushing, but elongated models tend to have more options to enhance performance.
Accessibility and Compliance
For those with mobility issues, elongated toilets offer better accessibility. The additional space makes it easier to transfer from a wheelchair or use support aids. Many elongated toilets also meet ADA-compliant standards, meaning they are designed to be accessible to all users, including those with disabilities.
Due to their smaller size, round toilets are less common in ADA-compliant designs. However, they can still be a practical choice in tight spaces where mobility aids might not be necessary. When choosing a toilet, consider the user’s specific needs to ensure maximum comfort and accessibility for everyone in the household.
Cost and Value
Choosing between an elongated or round toilet can impact your budget in both the short and long term. Consider initial prices and the long-term value each toilet type offers.
Price Comparison
Elongated toilets typically have a higher purchase price. A basic elongated model costs around $275 to $360, while a round toilet ranges from $225 to $310. Installation costs for both types vary from $45 to $130, depending on factors like pipe condition and toilet location.
While round toilets are generally cheaper upfront, the quality and brand can also affect the price. High-end features such as dual-flush mechanisms or advanced bowl technologies can drive up costs for either type.
Long-Term Value
Both types have pros and cons when it comes to long-term value. Elongated toilets are often considered more comfortable and, due to better design and performance, may reduce the likelihood of needing replacement or maintenance. This can save you money over time.
While sometimes less comfortable, round toilets can be easier to clean and maintain. Fewer parts may lead to lower maintenance costs. Choosing a toilet that fits well in your bathroom space and meets your comfort and usage needs will result in better long-term satisfaction and value.
Wrapping Up
Choosing between elongated and round toilets depends on your needs, space constraints, and personal preferences. Elongated toilets offer enhanced comfort and a modern look, making them popular for many households.
On the other hand, round toilets are perfect for smaller spaces and often come at a lower cost. Understanding each type’s unique benefits and drawbacks allows you to make a well-informed decision that balances comfort, functionality, and aesthetics.
We hope this comprehensive comparison guide has provided you with valuable insights into choosing the ideal toilet for your bathroom.
Frequently Asked Questions
When choosing between an elongated toilet and a round toilet, you will find differences in comfort, space requirements, and costs. Each type has its own pros and cons that could influence your decision.
What are the pros and cons of installing an elongated toilet versus a round toilet?
Elongated toilets are known for their oval-shaped bowl, providing more comfort for most adults. They often have a more powerful flush system, reducing the need to double flush. However, they require more room, making them less suitable for smaller bathrooms.
Their circular bowl makes round toilets more compact and fit better in tight spaces. They are typically less expensive and may be sufficient for smaller individuals or children. On the downside, they might not offer the same level of comfort as elongated toilets.
